The Salve and Vagisil

Vagisil is 20% benzocaine, a numbing agent. The Salve is nine organic ingredients.

Vagisil Maximum Strength Anti-Itch Creme uses benzocaine, a numbing agent. The Soothe & Restore Salve from Momotaro Apotheca takes a different approach: nine certified organic ingredients that moisturize and protect the skin of the vulva.

9certified organic ingredients in the Salve
0numbing agents, synthetic fragrance or parabens
4.9 ★from over 100,000 customers served
Soothe & Restore Salve by Momotaro Apotheca
Soothe & Restore Salve · $37

Certified organic comfort for the vulva

A plant-oil balm for itchy, dry or irritated vulvar skin, gentle enough to use every day.

★★★★★ 4.9 stars · Over 100,000 customers served

Shop the Salve

What are the downsides of Vagisil?

Vagisil Maximum Strength works by numbing the skin. Here's what its label and vulvar skin research say.

Benzocaine is a known vulvar allergen

In 90 women patch-tested for vulvar symptoms, benzocaine was the third most common culprit, after fragrance ingredients. Vagisil Maximum Strength is 20% benzocaine.

O'Gorman & Torgerson 2013, Dermatitis

It contains fragrance

Fragrance ingredients topped that same list of vulvar allergens. Dermatologists advise avoiding perfumed products on the vulva.

O'Gorman & Torgerson 2013 · British Association of Dermatologists

Numbing hides the itch, it doesn't fix it

The Cleveland Clinic calls buying over-the-counter anti-itch products for vulvar irritation a mistake that may make it worse. Vagisil's label says to stop if the itch lasts more than 7 days or keeps coming back.

Cleveland Clinic · Vagisil Drug Facts

An allergy alert on the box

The label says not to use it if you've ever reacted to a “-caine” numbing medicine.

Vagisil Drug Facts

What's in each one?

The Salve: 9 ingredients

  • Organic coconut oil
  • Organic kokum butter
  • Organic beeswax
  • Organic jojoba
  • Organic tea tree
  • Organic goldenseal
  • Organic echinacea
  • Organic calendula
  • Organic Oregon grape

All certified organic. From the Salve's listing.

Vagisil Maximum Strength

  • Benzocaine 20% (numbing agent)
  • Resorcinol 3%
  • Water, mineral oil
  • Propylene glycol
  • Cetyl alcohol
  • Fragrance
  • Methylparaben
  • Sodium sulfite
  • Plus 11 more inactive ingredients

From its Drug Facts label.

Why people choose the Salve

People who switch from anti-itch cremes often tell us they wanted fewer, simpler ingredients.

  • Certified organic, 9 ingredientsCoconut oil, kokum butter, beeswax, jojoba, tea tree, goldenseal, echinacea, calendula and Oregon grape. Nothing else.
  • Made for vulvar skinA silky balm that melts in and holds moisture where skin is dry, itchy or rubbed raw.
  • Gentle enough for every dayNo numbing agents, alcohol, parabens, silicones, sulfates or synthetic fragrance, so there's no 7-day limit on the box.
  • Developed with cliniciansMade by Momotaro Apotheca with input from OB-GYNs, naturopathic doctors and MDs.

What's been studied in the Salve's ingredients?

Studies of single ingredients, not of the Salve itself.

Tested in people254

Calendula

In a randomized trial of 254 women having radiation therapy, calendula ointment led to fewer cases of severe skin irritation than the standard cream.

Pommier 2004, J Clin Oncol
Tested in people121

Echinacea

Less itch, dryness and redness after 2 to 4 weeks of echinacea creams in 121 people.

Kilic 2018, Clin Cosmet Investig Dermatol
Tested in people53%

Jojoba

53% less water loss from irritated skin after 14 days, with less redness, scaling and cracking.

Rheins 2008, J Cosmet Sci
Tested in people34

Coconut oil

Worked as well as mineral oil for dry skin in a double-blind trial of 34 adults, with no irritation reported.

Agero & Verallo-Rowell 2004, Dermatitis

The Salve and Vagisil side by side

Soothe & Restore Salve Vagisil Maximum Strength
How it works on itch Moisturizes and protects the skin Numbs it with benzocaine 20%
How long you can use it Every day Label says ask a doctor if itch lasts over 7 days
Fragrance No synthetic fragrance Contains fragrance
Parabens None Contains methylparaben
Certified organic Yes No

Vagisil facts from its Drug Facts label and retail listing.

Questions people ask

Is the Salve better than Vagisil for itching?

They work differently. Vagisil numbs the skin for a while. The Salve moisturizes and protects it with plant oils, butters and herbs, and you can use it every day.

Can I use the Salve if I'm allergic to benzocaine?

The Salve has no benzocaine or other numbing agents. As with any new product, try a small amount on your inner arm first.

What if the itch doesn't go away?

Itching that lasts more than a week, or keeps coming back, is worth a visit to a clinician to check for yeast, BV or a skin condition.

Is the tea tree in the Salve safe on the vulva?

The Salve uses tea tree oil at about 2%. A review of 46 clinical trials found tea tree's side effects were mostly minor, with nearly all reactions at strengths of 25% or more. In the lab, friendly vaginal lactobacilli were unharmed by tea tree below 2%.

A light tingle is normal for some people. If you've reacted to tea tree before or your skin is very sensitive, try a small amount on your inner arm first, and stop if you get redness, swelling or a rash.

Kairey 2023, Front Pharmacol · Di Vito 2015, Phytother Res

This page is for general information and isn't medical advice. The Salve is a cosmetic balm and is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. If you think you have an infection, see a clinician. Vagisil is a trademark of its owner; Momotaro Apotheca is not affiliated with it. Reviewed by the Momotaro Apotheca medical team, including OB-GYNs and naturopathic doctors.

Reviewed by the Momotaro Apotheca medical team, including OB-GYNs and naturopathic doctors. Educational information, not medical advice. All ingredient research